Pi Coin (PI) is a cryptocurrency mining project that has garnered attention with its ambitious goal of becoming a global payment system. With a reported 35 million supporters, the project aims to make crypto mining more accessible, but there are growing concerns about its legitimacy. Could Pi Coin be the next big thing in the cryptocurrency world, or is it too good to be true? Let’s take a closer look at the facts, the concerns, and the future of Pi Network.
What Is Pi Network?
Launched in 2019 by a team of Stanford University graduates, Pi Network aimed to revolutionize cryptocurrency mining. Unlike energy-intensive coins like Bitcoin, Pi Coin can be mined using just a smartphone. Users tap a “Lightning” button in the app every few hours to earn coins. This simplicity has attracted a large user base, with Pi Network claiming to have over 35 million users globally, of which more than 12 million have completed the identity verification through Pi’s Know Your Customer (KYC) solution.
Pi Network’s promise of low-effort mining has helped it build a solid following, with its official Twitter account boasting 3.4 million followers in November 2024, which is on par with Ethereum’s social media presence. However, despite these impressive metrics, there are several red flags that could jeopardize the project’s long-term success.
Pi Network’s Mainnet Launch – Progress or Broken Promises?
One of the most pressing questions surrounding Pi Coin is the delay in the project’s open mainnet launch. The team has outlined several conditions for launching the open mainnet, including reaching 15 million KYC-verified users, migrating 10 million users to the beta mainnet, and having 100 mainnet-ready applications. As of August 2024, over 13 million users have passed KYC, and more than 6 million have migrated to the mainnet, but the network still has a long way to go.
The network has reached over 13 million Pioneers who have passed KYC and over 6 million Pioneers who have migrated to Mainnet! Through our collective efforts, we’re progressing towards the Open Network goals. Keep in mind that the progress is not linear and has been accelerating… pic.twitter.com/fXad6mpe59
— Pi Network (@PiCoreTeam) August 8, 2024
Analysts have raised concerns about the actual number of active wallets and the inflated circulating supply of Pi Coins. Reports indicate there could be a significant discrepancy between the number of actual wallets and the numbers Pi Network claims. Additionally, Pi Coin is still in its “enclosed mainnet” phase, meaning it cannot be traded on exchanges yet, which raises doubts about its future viability.
Pi Coin – Mining or Just Tapping?
One of the biggest criticisms of Pi Network is that its mining process doesn’t align with traditional cryptocurrency mining models. Bitcoin and Ethereum use energy-intensive Proof-of-Work (PoW) or Proof-of-Stake (PoS) mechanisms to secure their networks and validate transactions. In contrast, Pi mining only requires users to tap a button on their smartphones. While the simplicity of this process is appealing, critics argue that it doesn’t hold the same value as mining done through more conventional means.
Some even claim that Pi mining is more of a “tap-to-earn” model, similar to apps that reward users for watching ads or completing simple tasks. This has led to questions about whether the coins earned in this way will ever hold any real value.
The Role of Advertising in Pi Network
Pi Network generates revenue through advertisements in its app, a practice that has drawn mixed reactions from users. While some appreciate that users can opt out of ads, others feel that the app is overly reliant on ad revenue to sustain its operations. The use of ads to fund the project has led some to question whether Pi Network is truly focused on building a functional cryptocurrency ecosystem, or if it’s simply using ads as a revenue-generating tool.
Moreover, Pi’s data collection practices have raised concerns. The app collects extensive data, including personal details and app usage patterns, which is shared with third-party advertisers. While the project’s privacy policy states that it does not share personal data directly with ad networks, the amount of data gathered has left some users uneasy about their privacy.
Despite the concerns surrounding Pi Network, it’s important to note that the project still has potential. The user base is substantial, and the team’s goal of reaching 100 mainnet-ready apps suggests that they are working toward offering real utility. However, the success of Pi Coin will depend on whether it can deliver on its promises and whether the open mainnet launch will bring tangible value to users.
PiFest 2024 saw real-world engagement as Pi-powered businesses registered for the event—over 27,000 active and 28,000 test sellers from over 160 countries—and over 950,000 unique Pioneers used Map of Pi to browse and search for local stores to participate in PiFest. From bustling… pic.twitter.com/Sw2DCNMZMy
— Pi Network (@PiCoreTeam) November 23, 2024
As of now, Pi Network’s development has been slow compared to other blockchain projects like Ethereum and Cardano, which launched their mainnets within two years. Pi has surpassed five years without an open mainnet, which has led to speculation about whether the project is truly advancing or if it’s stuck in a perpetual state of delay.
Pi Network has undoubtedly gained a massive following, and its innovative approach to mining has attracted millions of users. However, the lack of a whitepaper, technical documentation, and an open mainnet launch leaves many questions unanswered. While the project could eventually succeed, the current lack of transparency and ongoing delays are significant red flags.
Ultimately, Pi Coin could become a legitimate cryptocurrency and payment system if the open mainnet launch is successful and it delivers real utility to users. However, the project is still in its early stages, and whether it can overcome its hurdles remains to be seen. For now, potential investors and users should remain cautious and keep an eye on future developments.
Disclaimer: The information in this article is for general purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. The author’s views are personal and may not reflect the views of Chain Affairs. Before making any investment decisions, you should always conduct your own research. Chain Affairs is not responsible for any financial losses.
About The Author
